späť

Why a brand is more than a symbol: The value of a brand in a competitive environment

The essence of a strong brand: What makes it credible and memorable

‍

The importance of the brand is also demonstrated by the work to protect reputable trademarks such as the brand COUGAR, Legal disputes show that reputation can be the most valuable asset, but also a source of challenges.

‍

In order for a brand to really work as a competitive advantage, it must be:

  • clearly identifiable,credible and consistent, involving effort, cost and time on the part of its owner (e.g. building a strong brand portfolio and protecting it),
  • Capable arouse emotionbefore the first contact with the product,
  • based on this, What customers say about you— not only in advertising, but in discussions and experiences with each other

‍

A strong brand is formed when:

  • Maintains consistent quality — the client knows exactly what they expect from you
  • communicates a clear story, mission and values,
  • evokes positive associations — success, innovation, lifestyle, etc.

‍

Branding as a competitive advantage: 4 reasons why it is worth investing in a brand

‍

  1. Higher price resistanceApple can charge a premium price because the brand brings value, not just the product.
  2. More effective marketing— A well-known brand does not need to be persuaded from scratch.
  3. Customer LoyaltyLoyalty comes from trust, even when fierce competition arises.
  4. Easier portfolio expansion— brands like Nike or PUMA are opening the door for new categories (e.g. from shoes to clothing).

‍

Behind every strong brand is a strong brand protection and brand building team (brand and enforcement team). Their task is not only to register rights, but also to monitor and protect them all over the world — in cooperation with state institutions (police, customs, courts). Thanks to continuous work and presence in the market, as well as awareness-raising activities (e.g. training of public sector employees), the position of a brand with a good name and reputation can be built.

‍

Puma vs. Adidas: The iconic rivalry that defined sports branding

‍

The story of brands Pumaa Adidasis a unique example of how a family split grew into a business rivalry that shaped sports marketing, brand building and understanding of intellectual property. For businesses, it's a textbook demonstration of how conflict and competition can accelerate innovation and strengthen brand identity. This article presents a case study that combines historical facts with current experience and shows what today's entrepreneurs, young innovators and start-ups can achieve.

The Dassler brothers,Rudolf and Adolf (Adi) started producing sports shoes in the 1920s in the family company Gebrüder Dassler Schuhfabrik. World success came already in 1936, when Jesse Owens won four gold medals in their tretrums at the OHV Berlin. However, after World War II, the brothers did not agree and split: Adi founded Adidas, Rudolf Asthma.

‍

Brand identity as a competitive weapon: The case of Adidas and Puma

‍

  • AdidasYou have built your identity through three stripes
  • Pumabet on the “jumping puma” logo and technological innovation
  • The two brands have been fighting over design, patents and marketing slogans since the 1950s
  • This fight has shown that the value of the brand lies not only in the products, but also in Visual and legal protection of identity

‍

Strong brands are not only born in the factory, but also on the field, in the media and in the minds of fans. Linking a product with emotion is the most powerful marketing tool.

‍

Protection of Intellectual Property in Litigation Practice

‍

The rivalry between Adidas and Puma was the basis of modern understanding Trademark, design and patent protection. Today, both companies are waging disputes with their competitors around the world in order to maintain leadership and leading position in the market.

‍

Dispute No. 1: Puma vs. Sun Day Red (Tiger Woods) — Tiger logo under the microscope

‍

In 2024, Puma filed an objection to the brand logo SundDay Red, which was founded by Tiger Woods in partnership with TaylorMade. The logo with the tiger, according to Puma, is too reminiscent of its iconic logo “Leaping Cat”. Puma's argument was based on the fact that both symbols represent predatory beasts in motion and act in the same segment — sportswear and footwear. According to Puma, there is a risk that consumers will confuse the logos, which would weaken its brand identity.

On the contrary, Sun Day Red's lawyers argue that the tiger logo is different in style, in graphic processing and also in symbolism, and therefore the probability of confusion between the signs is not given.

For now, the dispute continues and may set a precedent in how the similarity of animal motifs in logos will be judged.

‍

Dispute No. 2: Puma vs. Brooks Sports — “Nitro” Trademark in Litigation

‍

This dispute concerned designs and trademarks fortechnologies of running shoes.

The focus of the conflict was the use of the name “Nitro”, which Puma has been using for its cushioning technology in the soles since 2021. Brooks Sports began marketing running shoes in which it used the same designation.

Puma argued that this was a violation of its rights and misuse of the brand, which could undermine its unique marketing communications and reputation in the market. The dispute was resolved in federal courts in the United States, and although the two sides initially prepared a large-scale legal battle, they eventually reached an out-of-court settlement.

‍

Dispute No. 3: Puma vs. Van Hilst BV — Disclosure of design before registration

‍

The European General Court (Case T-647/22) ruled that one of the Puma designs (registered as an EU Community design) is invalid.

The reason was that Puma itself posted images of this design on social networks (Instagram) even before its official registration.

The complainant pointed, inter alia, to three posts containing images taken from the account “badgalriri” on Instagram, dated December 16, 2014, each of which received more than 300000 likes, in which it was stated that Robyn Rihanna Fenty (“Rihanna”) had been appointed as the new creative director of PUMA and that a contract had been signed to that effect, in these photos Rihanna was shown in white shoes with thick black soles.

According to European law, a design must have an element of “novelty” and “individual character” for protection — the publication of the product itself by pre-registration could not meet these conditions, which is why it was too late to declare the design invalid.

This decision is therefore a warning to all innovators and manufacturers of new products to always align their marketing presentation in advance with the strategy of protecting intellectual property rights.

‍

Dispute No. 4: Puma vs. Fujian Daocheng — The Individual Character of Design Before the EU Court

‍

Puma tried challenge the designregistered by the Chinese company Fujian Daocheng Electronic Commerce Co., which, according to her, did not have sufficient individual character and was too similar to the Puma designs.

The legal context of the case was based on the provisions of the Regulation dealing with invalidity of the Community design on grounds of lack of individual character. According to these articles, a design is considered to be a design with an individual character if it produces a different overall impression in the informed user compared to any earlier design.

The General Court examined whether earlier designs had been sufficiently publicised, identifying an informed user as a high-attention shopper who routinely buys shoes. The court also assessed the degree of freedom of the designer in creating shoe designs and found it to be quite high. The court compared the contested design with the older designs, taking into account the overall impression that each one evokes. He found that the challenged design was markedly different from the older designs in terms of decoration, sole structure and upper properties, resulting in a different overall impression in the informed user.

PUMA based its arguments in particular on the comparison of soles, which should have been the primary basis for the comparison made by the General Court.

The court emphasized that the overall impression should be based on the entire design, not just individual parts. The differences in the decorative elements, the configuration of the upper and the structure of the sole were significant enough to create a different overall impression.

Consequently, the General Court dismissed Puma's action and confirmed that the contested design was of an individual character.

Thus, Puma did not succeed in the dispute, which shows that the arguments for similarity must be very concrete and convincing. This case highlights the complexity of international disputes and the different perceptions of the originality of designs in different jurisdictions.

‍

Thus, the above cases from practice show that:

  • Even visual similarities in logos can cause serious legal disputes,
  • the use of technological names (such as “Nitro”) requires a consistent branding strategy,
  • hasty disclosure of the design may jeopardize its legal protection,
  • In international disputes, detailed argumentation and differences between legal systems are decisive.

‍

Investing in patents, trademarks and designs is just as important as investing in manufacturing or marketing. Intellectual property protection is a guarantee that the value of a brand remains in the hands of its creator.

‍

Examples of strong brands from the world: What makes Apple, Tesla, Starbucks and Nike special?

‍

  • Apple:builds a premium image not only through technology, but also through design, ecosystem and emphasis on protecting design rights. A strong brand allows you to charge premium prices.
  • Tesla:Its brand is synonymous with innovation and sustainability. Although competitors offer similar technologies, the Tesla name has a weight that attracts both customers and investors.
  • Starbucks:does not just sell coffee, but the “coffee shop experience”. A strong brand has enabled worldwide expansion and resilience to local competition.
  • Nike:Like Puma or Adidas, it has proven that by combining sport, emotion and iconic personalities (Michael Jordan, Serena Williams), we can build a brand that goes beyond the product itself.

‍

5 Key Lessons for Business: How to Build and Protect a Strong Brand

‍

  1. Design and logo are assets:Brand protection has a direct impact on its value.
  2. Innovations should be protected by patents/designs:technical solutions become a marketing trump card.
  3. Marketing identity is about stories:Sports icons orsymbolic moments are the most powerful brand building tool.
  4. Rivalry can be an engine of growth:competition brings pressure that leads to innovation and greater resilience of the brand.
  5. Examples from practice show universality:be it sports, technology or coffee, the brand must be seen as capital.

‍

Building a brand requires both strategy and legal protection

‍

The story of Puma vs. Adidas is not just a family drama, it's chaptersin the history of branding and intellectual property. It shows that protecting a logo, design or patent is not a formality, but a key element of building long-term value.

For today's companies, a clear message flows from this: the brand is not a product, but a comprehensive identity that must be constantly protected and strategically developed. No matter the industry — from technology, to automotive, fashion to coffee — a brand is a tool that turns a product into a story and a story into a trust.

If you want your brand to stand up in a competitive environment, gain the trust of customers and withstand legal challenges, you need not only creative, but also experienced lawyers in the field of intellectual property. A properly set protection strategy for a logo, design, name or technology can be the difference between growth and loss of value.

So let this article be an inspiration for you, and at the same time an impulse to take the next step. Connect with intellectual property law experts to build a brand with global reach that not only has a strong story, but also solid legal protections.

‍